Inglorious Bettas
  • Home
  • About Me
  • Blog
  • Spawning Bettas
    • Let's Talk Bettas!
    • Setting up the Fish Room
    • Indian Almond Leaf (IAL)
    • Fish Photography for Spawn Logs
    • Selective Breeding
    • Spawning Set-ups
    • How Bettas Spawn
    • Fry Foods
    • Grow-out Tanks
    • Jarring
    • Maintenance of Adults
    • Culling
  • Spawn Logs
    • Metallic Crowntail Plakats >
      • CTPK Spawn Journal >
        • CTPK color 031814
        • CTPK form 042014
        • CTPK form 020815
        • CTPK color 020815
        • CTPK color 072115
        • CTPK combo 030116
        • CTPK combo 011017
    • Red/Yellow Traditional Plakats >
      • Genealogical Chart
      • RY Trad PKs Spawn Journal >
        • RY Trad 112512 Thanksgiving
        • RY Trad 040613
        • RY Trad 072013
        • RY Trad/Show 020114
        • RY Trad 031814
        • RY Trad 072115
        • RY Trad 080715
    • Crowntail Doubletails >
      • Genealogical Chart
      • CTDT Spawn Journal >
        • CTDT 051812
        • CTDT 081412
        • CTDT 102012
        • CTDT 011213
        • CTDT 021413 Valentine's Day
        • CTDT 050313
        • CTDT 081313
        • CTDT 021414 - Valentine's Day - Repeat Spawn
    • Black Traditional Plakats >
      • Black Trad Plakat Spawn Journal >
        • Black Trad 042014
        • Black Trad 072414
  • Fish Shows
    • Show Reports
    • How to Send Bettas to a Show
    • What Does it Take to Become an IBC judge?
  • Wilds & Killifish
    • Betta rubra
    • Elassoma species affinis evergladei Elberta, Alabama
    • Heterandria formosa
    • Blue Gularis "Niger Delta" (Aphyosemion sjoestedti)
    • Betta burdigala
    • Blue Gularis "Loe" (Aphyosemion sjoestedti)
    • Betta smaragdina
    • Aphyosemion bitaeniatum Ijebu-Ode
  • Betta Science
    • Betta Education
    • Betta genetics: color and form
    • Sex determination in bettas
    • Betta behavior
    • Betta spawning
  • Links

Sex Reversal and Determination in Bettas

8/8/2013

6 Comments

 
Who knows what determines sex in bettas? A pair of researchers try to figure it out.
Picture
Thomas Lowe and Jeanne Larkin used various breeding, surgical, and histological techniques to try and figure out whether sex determination in bettas was XY and XX like it is in humans.
Betta Sex Determination…who knows what the answer is?

We’ve all had spawns that turn out all (or nearly all) female, or occasionally have more males.  For betta breeders especially, figuring out how to produce mostly male offspring would be the equivalent of sliced bread for the betta hobby. Yet, despite years and years of dedicated breeding, no one knows what can really determine sex in bettas, let alone the molecular mechanism behind it. There are still wild myths in the hobby, and some even wilder scientific conjectures backed by numerous and conflicting studies!

I chose this paper because it had a relatively large sample size compared to most other studies, which gives strength to its conjectures. Previous, smaller studies had shown that spayed females gained male characteristics, and this could even occur spontaneously. In this study, Lowe and Larkin at Western Illinois University wanted to figure out whether male bettas potentially had heterogametic (XY) sex determinants, as compared to homogametic (XX) female sex determinants, like humans and many other kinds of animals. They reasoned that a sex-reversed female to male (by surgically removing the ovaries) would still be genetically homogametic (XX), and even if this sex-reversed female (called a “neomale”) was able to mate and produce offspring, it would produce all female offspring (“neomale” XX x normal female XX = females XX only).

First, they bred normal males and females together to get enough stock to perform the experiments. Males were separated in quart jars while females were kept together in large tanks until use (potential caveat: some males do not show female characteristics until removed from the grow out tank!). In all, 245 characteristic females had their ovaries surgically removed. About 2/3 of the fish survived. 56 (or 22.9%) actually regenerated their ovaries and remained female. Another 104 (or 42.5%) became sex-reversed “neomales”. They gained male characteristics, and were later surgically examined and found to have generated a “testes” - an odd bladder-like structure from the cut site that was dissimilar to normal males, but nevertheless produced viable sperm.

The researchers next mated the neomales with normal females. Although not all attempts produced viable offspring, the researched were surprised that 3 out of the 11 spawning attempts that produced viable offspring were comprised of both male and female offspring! This meant that sex determination in bettas could not be based on male heterogametic (XY) and female homogametic (XX) determinants. 

The authors bring up many past discussions on sex determination in their discussion, including Dr. Gene Lucas’ studies that say that mating a younger male to an older female will produce more males, as well as imperfect water conditions (observations shared by some but not all other betta researchers). Due to the production of both male and female offspring from sex-reversed females, the authors conclude that perhaps there is a brain-centered sex determinant that, once triggered as a female (the “default sex”), must be maintained as female by hormones originating from the ovaries. Once the ovaries are removed, these hormones are no longer produced, and androgens are capable of turning it into a fully functional male. The authors also speculate that sex determination occurs on the gene level rather than the chromosomal level in bettas, although one older paper reports the existence of two potential sex chromosomes that were slightly larger, this finding was unfounded in later studies). This gene level of determination may be derived from the possible mixing of several different betta “species” from different locales, which were divergent enough to have different sex determinant systems but could still interbreed. With the rampant mixing of bettas from many different regions, the sex determinant systems could have become faulty.

Lowe TH and Larkin LR. Sex reversal in Betta splendens Regan with emphasis on the problem of sex determination. J Exp Zool. 1975 Jan;191(1):25-32.

6 Comments
Claire link
8/8/2013 06:16:28 pm

Thanks for digging this out.
We still don't really know how sex is determined in Bettas, but at least this experiment gives us some clues, and hopefully others will continue searching.
I personally don't mind not knowing what determines their sex and will be happy with whatever surprises pop up in a spawn. ^^

Reply
wolfman jenkins
5/25/2017 12:55:34 am

As for me I breeding a male smaragdina fighter bettafish with a female halfmoon Bettafish to make the greatest fighter bettafish since MUHAMMAD ALI.

Reply
Gianne link
8/9/2013 03:13:26 am

Thanks for the reply Claire! I hope that researchers are able to isolate the sex determination, because it seems so wild and plastic. Sex determination on the gene level seems very interesting!

Practically, though, I enjoy the surprise as well! :)

Just looked around you and Jean-Michel's website! Jean-Michel has some excellent bettas! I hope the ones you guys took back from convention made the trip safely :) I especially love the page of book reviews, I wish a couple of those interesting books were in English (like Peter's book lol).

Reply
wolfman jenkins
5/25/2017 12:59:51 am

I'm breeding a special batch of bettafish to raise the babies for training and more training then enter the Amatures and win 10 bouts then champion fighting and win 20 fights these Will literally be the greatest bettafish since MUHAMMAD ALI.

Reply
wolfman jenkins
5/25/2017 12:28:08 am

The halmoon is my favorite favorite favorite favorite​ bettafish I'm breeding a female halfmoon plakat bettafish​ with a male smaragdina fighter plakat bettafish to make the greatest bettafish since MUHAMMAD ALI. He will beat all bettafish.

Reply
wolfman jenkins
5/25/2017 01:02:23 am

That's right everyone I'm breeding my secret bettafish to make babies for fighting and beating all bettas long or short fin or crowntail AH HA HA HA HA HA HAAA.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Categories

    All
    Betta Science!
    Fishroom Tours
    Fish Talks
    Local Fish Store Visits
    News
    Show Stuff
    Spawn Updates
    Special
    Tips And Tricks
    Wilds

    Archives

    October 2020
    August 2017
    July 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013

    RSS Feed

Copyright © 2017